Ok, I'll try that. With another V-divider, I guess?
EDIT: Ok, took 2 1K5 resistors, one from 15V to the non-inverting input of the opamp and the other from the non-inverting to ground. Seems to have fixed the varying wave on the scope, but it's still not 100%. They seem to light very close to one-another, without much difference in the gain knob.
At 21V P-P none are lit, I turn the gain up a bit on the preamp and the 2nd LED lights ??? .. This is 21.2-21.4V P-P. At 24V the other 2 LEDs light.
I guess I still have to mess with my V-dividers, but why does the 2nd LED light first?