Some metal guitar players report about whopping 4-5 volts p-t-p from the hottest passive pickups on the market.
My Modulus bass overloads ADCs. Because of its insane signal level this is the way how I record it when I need a "clean" signal, it's just an active buffer, without preamps, etc. It works fine for fingers, can't handle the slap, though, without attenuation. Yes, instruments like this are rare, but they exist. I call this bass "the metal hate machine" because of its output and very aggressive sound.
BTW. RSRecords, may be you find some ideas here. It was implemented with the ADA4627 and a pair of the LM4562. The primary "floating" output is +6 dB, the "zero impedance" outputs can be easily configured to gain. The schematic can be implemented with an only one quad low noise FET op-amp at the cost of the one "ZI" output.