@ Abbey.
To maintain context:
The horror story is to be focussed on a reluctance to pro-actively support non-broadcast, small-time, private or personal studio operators who are NOT in the league of spending mega-bucks on a new console..... in the corporate world these small guys are not able to provide a profitable revenue stream - that is the problem.
Technically, there are no issues.
Here is my take on that statement, with a particular focus on S-Series:
The last of the analogue consoles were put through production several years ago - everything is now digital and focussed on digital.
On personal experience of a working relationship with Calrec that spans decades, I can say from first-hand, the quality of the analogue consoles is top-notch both in terms of build and design - up there with Studer is about right. There is nothing wrong with the durability; it is the way the consoles are maintained by their owners (or not maintained) that is the problem. *Since 1993 the focus has been to design with SMD. This required a whole new set of skills in terms of design and manufacture; out in the field, there is also a whole new set of skills required for maintenace and repair. Some console owners have the maintenace skills available, some don't, some contract-in the skills, some drop into butcher mode through ignorance or tight-wallets.
* The start of my first R&D contract in 1993 co-incided, within a month, with the arrival of Calrec's SMD assembly equipment. It was a fantastic experience to be in at the beginning of that new era.
The fact that Davis Aurora's customer's previous tech has been described as a butcher cannot be laid at the door of the manufacturer.
As tech-savvy people we all know that electrolytic caps dry-out, go high ESR and audio suffers. The answer is to replace the caps. In my business we have been doing this on Neve VRs and Calrec M, S and Q series consoles for years. The Neve VRs and Calrec M's require standard through-hole tools and equipment, the Calrec S and later Q SMD products require specialist SMD tools - in my business we have invested in these and as a result, unless the boards are already damaged, we do no damage in our repair & service processes..... in the technical services industry you get what you pay for.
In regards to the leaking capacitors, it is unfortunate that a particular cap type/manufacturer was chosen. I am not privy to the decision making process surrounding the choice of cap/supplier/manufacturer, so will not speculate. Calrec is not the only manufacturer to have had problems with eletrolytics: theirs is the SMD equivalent of the 1990's Neve VR cap replacement project.
Components have improved greatly in a quarter century.
IIRC the Neve 55 had a similar SMD cap issue with regard to leaking.
Hindsight is a wonderful thing.
@ Gyraf.
The only UA8000 I have worked on was the one in Studio 3 at Abbey Road in 1989, and even then my involvement was minimal. I cannot really comment on the UA8000 due to the lack of detailed personal experience. There certainly was a heck of a lot of electronics in a very small space. To achieve the component packing density with a through-hole design was impressive at the time - it still is impressive today.
I know the inflexible break-because-they-can ribbons that you note. A thoroughly nasty interconnect component! Unfortunately, there were very few choices back then.
The UA8000 is a product design that was likely a decade or two ahead of its time in terms of facilities and was ideally suited to the packing densities of SMD and the tight component tolerances that today are simply taken for granted - I'm thinking of the modern That Corp VCAs, 0.1% resistors, 1% capacitors, temperature compensating components, multilayer PCBs, flat-flexi ribbons and other 21st century PCB interconnect technology.
The sandwiching of switches, as you describe, is frankly unforgivable
and on some M-Series has caused me more than one sense of humour failure accompanied by excessive swearing.... and that's before starting on the delicate dis-assembly procedure to get to the failed switch latch!