electrostatic, electromagnetic, etc

GroupDIY Audio Forum

Help Support GroupDIY Audio Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Bo Deadly

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 22, 2015
Messages
3,266
Location
New Jersey, USA
I got this book for xmas and I'm just now getting around to reading it. I thought I understood E pretty well but this book is going to get me to another level. Electrons move through conductors with an average velocity of 0.001 in/s. It's the electric (E and D) and magnetic (H and B) fields that are actually transmitting all signals / information / power in circuits.
Related to this is this interesting video:



which claims that electrons deflected by a current flowing through a wire near by is not because of a generated magnetic field but instead by simple Coulomb's law when you consider the effects of "length contraction" and "time dilation" from Einstein's theory of relativity.
 
Related to this is this interesting video:



which claims that electrons deflected by a current flowing through a wire near by is not because of a generated magnetic field but instead by simple Coulomb's law when you consider the effects of "length contraction" and "time dilation" from Einstein's theory of relativity.

He is good at explaining things simply but I am not sure about that. Coulomb's law does not deal with electric fields, let alone time varying electric/magnetic fields.

He also suggests to dispense with electric field and magnetic field, and only work under the umbrella of electromagnetic field, but really? I have not looked up who he is, but if he is, as a hot-shot physicist's point of view he may prefer to do that reduction but how is that going to work from electrical engineering point of view?
 
I know this will come as a bit of a shock but perhaps a bit of a historical context is in order here.

When Coulomb carried out his experiment and published his findings the concept of fields did not exist, let alone electric or magnetic fields. Electricity and magnetism were accepted as completely two separate disciplines and there was no connection between the two. So, as far as the force between two points was concerned, the force acted on them and nothing else existed between the two.

The concept of electric and/or magnetic field did not happen until Faraday (a great man). Even then he could not really formulate it which happened with Maxwell (the greatest ever).

So, as far as Coulomb's law goes, it states that the force between two points-objects (in a vacuum) is proportional to the forces on each points, and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between the two points. That's it. The connection with electric or magnetic field is a later development. Now, the original form of the law is a mathematical tool for us. Replace the force in Coulomb's law with electric field strength, now you are dealing with the electric field between the two points.

So, the claim that electrons deflected by a current flowing through a wire near by is not because of a generated magnetic field but instead by simple Coulomb's law, in my opinion is wrong. Because the original form of the law also does not contain the terms that deal with the effects of "length contraction" and "time dilation" from Einstein's theory of relativity as it is also a (much) later development.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top