Our tastes represent opposite ends of the spectrum.
Of course, and I would venture to guess you're not a bebop guitar player, hence what appeals to you. The tone is also not the only consideration (and you're definitely right that weight and portability is a consideration that sold lots of these) in picking an amp (for any genr/gig). I had a Redplate for a while. Absolutely beautiful amp from circuit to construction to sound. However, it was downright terrible for playing bebop . It was like a damn cannon attached to your picking hand. You could kill the poor couple having a glass of wine sitting in the firing line of the amp if you leaned into a note too hard!!! Great amp for a blues gig, not so much for bebop. I've have a bunch of great amps, 64 BFSR, Redplate (sold), an all octal 40w, a Dumble clone, silverface fender, Marshall, etc... My Polytone amps are the most used ones believe it or not. They are just perfect for that straight ahead jazz tone, which is what I'm doing most of the time.
And let's be clear, if you set one down next to my 64 super reverb, the Fender sounds better. The Fender also shares that desirable feel for playing bebop. I'm certain that's what appealed to all those guys who came from playing big Fenders. I'm not immune to preferences either. I just can't get into Vox amps clean sound. I know, I know, blasphemy...
Anyway, all the conversation here is not meant to be hostile, just honest discussion. Hell, we have at least 2 Polytone fans in the thread so far, maybe another hater will chime in and even the score. Your offer is very generous btw, much appreciated.