Most of you folks don't know me, but I earn my living recording and mixing music for film & tv underscore, video games, theme parks, etc. The fairly recent postings in this topic kind of pushed a hot button for me because, in particular, the banzai/Maiku mic I built specifically for snare drum (which, among other things, incorporates George Massenburg's suggested KM84 mod--you can find it by doing a search), to me, sounds fantastic and has ended my 20 year search for
my snare drum mic; obviously YMMV.
On the 4 previously-posted sound examples, I was interested to try corrective eq as an experiment because, based on what I heard, I would need to do that with both mics if I was mixing. My methodology was to attempt to
only subtract problems (and I was pretty faithful to that), but to leave the basic personality of the capsule in place so I could get a deeper understanding of what each capsule was about sonically.
I attached audio files and EQ screenshots, for anyone interested, and used the same basic settings for both A versions and both B versions; none of them are 100% the same though. The main problems that were bugging me were too much on the bottom and a couple of body resonances (the same idea as wolf tones in orchestral celli). I really tried to touch the files with eq as minimally as possible, yet get to what I felt was a basic, professionally-acceptable result.
I know pretty much exactly what I think about the results
for what I like* but I thought some here might like to have a clearer picture of the type of result they might achieve with either capsule in a mix situation so they can clarify how they feel about their personal choices and criticisms.
The EQ was done with a GML 8200 and the settings captured with Waves' Q-Clone; a Topping D90 was the DA and a BLA White Sparrow was the AD for the hardware insert... all very short cable runs used in the analog chain, probably 12' or less.
https://www.dropbox.com/s/aonjomdbtkx5df6/ Maiku vs 3UAudio In Banzai DIY84_24-48 Wave.zip?dl=0
To refresh you, A = 3UAudio, B = Maiku
*and there were things to like in both capsules
for me