Wait a second. I guess I read your email too fast. The secondary winding and DCR should be between pins 5 and 8 not 5 and 6. Pin 6 is the internal screen and gets grounded. If pin 5 has continuity to pin 6 then that is indeed the issue.Thanks for the reply
Readings:
1-3 62.0
2-4 68.9
5-6 1.567
1 to can OL
2 to can OL
3 to can OL
4 to can OL
5 to can OL
6 to can OL
7 to can 0.6
8 to can OL
Jeff says this fully checks out. Transformer orientation was correct. I can’t explain it other than to say it didn’t work in two different preamps but the one I swapped from a working preamp did. I’m an engineer and I don’t believe in coincidences, and for me to solder it bad twice I wouldn't have thought likely, but I can't exclude it.
Jeff was nice enough to get a replacement off to me. I'll send him this one and see how he makes out with it.