[quote author="NewYorkDave"]This is off-topic, I know, but an interesting thought just occurred to me...
Have you noticed that many people who did things the "old school" way back when it was the only way seem to have no desire to go back to the old equipment and techniques? For my part, I haven't met anyone lately over the age of 40 who records to tape or has any interest in doing so. Most people who were working in the biz back when tape was the only game in town have memories of tedious hours spent with the blade and editing block, tape spills and broken tapes, hours spent cleaning and degaussing heads and aligning tape machines, fighting the Sisyphean battle against tape noise buildup during bounces, reductions and dubs...
Not many of these older guys talk about missing the "warmth"; rather, they seem to have this attitude of "thank God we don't have to deal with THAT anymore." Meanwhile, younger guys who have grown up with computer-based recording have a very romantic conception of how things must have been in the "old days." Naively perhaps, many seek the panacea of a tube, a transformer or a little tape in the signal path to recapture the lost magic of yesterday's recordings.
It's kind of like when I was first coming up in electronics. I thought tubes were the ultimate for audio--and I still do. But all the older guys I met, guys who had used, built and even designed with tubes back in the "golden age", dismissed such notions with a wave of the hand. "Tubes are dead", they'd say. "Why on earth would you want to use them nowadays, when we have transistors?" :wink:[/quote]
I have noticed (even been apart of )the same phenomena, especially being one who came up through recording using a computer. The more I have studied the recordings I like, I think I have finaly come to a correct conclusion about what makes a good record sound good (despite gear manufacturers and recording magazines telling us we this that and the other thing).
Its the band and their instruments! The gear used did impart its own color on the sound, but a great recording is 95% the music. It seems like what is considered that vintage sound may be more of the fact that bands were well rehearsed, played together and didn't time align/cut n paste everything using Alishad. Sonicaly the old stuff does sound different. Worse actually, but the bands had such a great thing going on that our minds ignore the lack of fidelity and really get into the music. Which brings up another thought. I generally prefer old B&W films without all the special efx. Sure some of the props were less realistic, but your caught up with the story and your mind tunes out the fact that the props are cheesy and the film is in black and white. Special efx today are on the verge of realism, but my mind notices that the sp. efx aren't 100% realistic and it stands out more to me than in older films. Maybe thats another reason we think we like vintage is because music back then wasn't overproduced, made perfect, and filled out with sound efx. Another reason we may think we like "vintage" is the recording techniques that were used when the said "vintage" gear was new. In many ways I think that they were truer to the sound of listening to a band play together in a room (except for those mono L-C-R recordings... the still sound cool anyway). The sound of snares and toms at 3" doesn't sound as real as being in the same room as the kit. For one, those are very dry sounds, but also air and distance tend to smooth transients. Now I wouldn't say that it is wrong to use these modern techniques, its all art and there are different kinds of art that require different tools and techniques, but perhaps when we think we want "vintage" sound, maybe its not as much gear as it is performance and micing techniques.
Don't get me wrong, I love vintage stuff, but I wish someone would have clued me in a few years ago to what I am finaly figuring out now.
I still would like to but less dependant on computers. Using the computer for recording and processing has forced me to learn things I am not interested in. Computers are high maintance (And have caused me a great deal of stress with a band in the studio). Old gear can be too, but at least I am interested in it...
Phewww, thats a mouthful. I had to get it off my chest, and my wife wouldn't understand. :wink: