bxt403
Well-known member
Gustav said:bxt403 said:Firstly- I think we're on a different page (given I was under the impression we BOTH were understanding the problem : you seemed to address the issue nicely and read that I desoldered the wires). [/URL]
I am not sure what went wrong, but as long as the center tap is connected, like the latest picture shows, thats good.
bxt403 said:I'm certain I'm getting the right voltages for the power supply
Great, would you mind posting the values, just so we can verify?
bxt403 said:At the end of the day- the only things I need to know is where on the circuitboard (that I've more or less ruled out) should I look for abnormalities w.r.t. the SC toggle not having any effect; along with the majority of the front panel controls. Keep in mind I'm passing audio (and the GAIN knob's working when the BP switch is off) so I only want to know the general area of where to look w.r.t. no compression occurring.
Passing audio is good, but its impossible to guess what the exact issue is. Its best to exclude the most basic variables first, so - you already mentioned you found one error on your bypass switch wiring, so there could be another, but before doing that...
bxt403 said:this build's power supply voltages are all measuring in the proper ranges
It would be extremely beneficial to trouble shooting if you would post the values.
bxt403 said:The other thing I'm thinking is perhaps switching out older component values from prior revisions- as the posted schematic includes the design changes (as it might be related to using a 2180B vs 2181B).
I found this page to be useful ( http://diy.fischerworks.com/gssl_vca.shtml )- as the person referenced the THAT data sheets for the 2180 and 2181.
Note: the PCB-Grinder kit I have came with the 2180B and "Matt's DIY Pages" seems to indicate that the THAT datasheets have the circuit board set-up (with the 5K1 resistor and "%" elsewhere in the Left/Right VCA sections) for the 2180- although Pages 2 & 3 of the GSSL schematic list that Rev. 9 incorporates the THAT 2181 under the "Revision History" heading. Also there's a discrepancy between the 120K* resistor (that's pink on "Matt's DIY Pages" and is valued at 100K). The footnote at the bottom of Page 1 of the schematic states "FOR THAT2180 VCA's DISCONNECT PIN4" but noticed that those pins are open and the components aren't populated on the Rev. 11 circuit board I have so am certain the 2180Bs that came with the "Full Kit" I bought don't need to be modified.
I am sorry if I was not clear earlier.
Looking for alternative IC brands, turbo boards, PSU filter boards, looking for traces to cut and values to change is a waste of time. Your unit is not compressing, so you have a basic build error or component failure.
Edit: If you are unsure of how to check the voltages, let us know ,so we can properly help. Its not a problem if you dont know, but its a problem if its the reason you are not giving feedback on voltages.
Gustav
It turned out to be the adapter cable I was using (mini-plug from my Macbook Pro 1/8" audio out to stereo XLR): I had one for input to the GSSL and one for output to my Objective 2 headphone amplifier).
The output cable was working fine (and was wired correctly with a 150 Ohm resistor connected between pins 2 & 3). The input cable going into the GSSL was wired in reverse (in that it was wired for an XLR-M but had pins 1 & 3 connected on an XLR-F connector to an XLR-M to M barrel adapter). I didn't notice the barrel connector compensates for the pin reversal until I replaced the XLR-F with a proper XLR-M.
Prior to testing with a properly wired test cable, I changed the Signetics NE5534As and NE5532As that were installed instead of the stock T.I. NE553xPs- with Signetics NE553xNs; along with changing the TL072 from a new one to an older one I have.
Also- I noticed that a Rev. 7 or Rev. 8 board seems to need 127 K Ohm resistor installed where it's labelled as 120K* on Rev. 9 or later (as it's listed on Gyraf GSSL page):
Knowing 120K is for the THAT 2181, according to the table (at http://diy.fischerworks.com/gssl_vca.shtml). My research (thus far) indicates (verifying from the PCB photos at audiokitchen) is that the 100K Ohm value (and DBX 2150) is at least up to the Rev. 7 PCB and 127K Ohm is for the THAT 2181 & 2180 (from the picture from the GSSL page on Gyraf's website but is contradictory to the Gyraf Rev. 9 schematic & "Matt's DIY Pages").
The table at "Matt's DIY Page" indicates the proper value is 120 KOhm (and the 127 K Ohm value listed on the Gyraf page implies that 120 K Ohm value listed for the 2181 on the Rev.9 (along with the Rev. 11 & Rev. 12) schematic also applies to the 2180 (but it isn't mentioned on the schematic). It's safest to assume that the 127K Ohm value might need to be double checked; given I'd rather not waste any more time trying to figure out if the 127K Ohms is correct or not on Rev. 8 or earlier versions of the GSSL: where the DBX 2150 is labelled at the 3 VCA slots that are labelled as THAT 2181 on the Rev. 11 boards I have (that's consistent with the Rev. 11/12 schematic that's posted at PCB Grinder at the time of this post).
Furthermore- it seems like you're better off finding an older Rev. circuit board (Rev. 8 or earlier) if you want to implement the DBX 2150; conversely- use a Rev.9 (or later) board if you want to implement the THAT 2181 or 2180 (knowing that the silkscreening on the Rev. 11 boards I was provided were labelled consistently to accommodate the THAT 2180- despite having "THAT 2181" silkscreened).
Also- it looks like Rev. 11 incorporates the CRC & HP filter so it's a safe assumption that adding an external CRC filter (like the one from EXPAT Audio) is redundant (and a waste of space, time and money for any people who are using the Rev. 11 or later circuit board). The compression seems to be more noticabe with the 553xP/N that the 553xAP/AN installed at the input and output but I've only used Signetics (N & AN) ICs (since they're true to the SSL design) so am not sure of how the newer Texas Instruments P & AP versions of the 553x op amps sound (w.r.t. to the original SSL circuit).
Finally: I'm thinking the SSL X-Logic Bus Compressor (or any current SSL Bus Compressor variation) is going to sound closer to Duende Native (in that you're going to hear the authentic SSL sound- albeit Duende's Bus Compressor is based around the 4000 G Series) while I'm inferring the GSSL is an optimized and/or improved version of the 4000 E. I can only compare my build to SSL's Duende Native's Bus Compressor (and my GSSL doesn't sound as "SSL-y" but suspect it's because Duende is meant to sound more like an optimized version of the 4000 G).