The big question is - what are we trying to protect?
With a zener diode in place of D1 to limit the differential voltage to less than 40 volts across the LM317 - the current to the zener must be limited - or it will fail short circuit!
This will protect the regulator, but will allow high voltage, unregulated current to pass to the load.
The moist common problem when building, experimenting or testing a new circuit is an accidental short circuit to earth - so under this condition - we want all components to survive and carry on working when the short is removed!
Later, during its service life, components might fail - an output capacitor might go short - but there is not much else to go wrong on the supply side of a Phantom circuit.
I limit the zener current with a 680R resistor, but this also limits the current to the regulator under normal operation - so the circuit I have designed is only good to feed one or two Phantom channels.
I always have an additional capacitor (10uF) from pin 1 of the regulator to earth to greatly improve ripple rejection - and it is then essential to have another protection diode across R2 (240R) - positive towards the 48 volt output.
With a zener diode in place of D1 to limit the differential voltage to less than 40 volts across the LM317 - the current to the zener must be limited - or it will fail short circuit!
This will protect the regulator, but will allow high voltage, unregulated current to pass to the load.
The moist common problem when building, experimenting or testing a new circuit is an accidental short circuit to earth - so under this condition - we want all components to survive and carry on working when the short is removed!
Later, during its service life, components might fail - an output capacitor might go short - but there is not much else to go wrong on the supply side of a Phantom circuit.
I limit the zener current with a 680R resistor, but this also limits the current to the regulator under normal operation - so the circuit I have designed is only good to feed one or two Phantom channels.
I always have an additional capacitor (10uF) from pin 1 of the regulator to earth to greatly improve ripple rejection - and it is then essential to have another protection diode across R2 (240R) - positive towards the 48 volt output.