Silver solder?

GroupDIY Audio Forum

Help Support GroupDIY Audio Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

mathtracks

Active member
Joined
Nov 14, 2004
Messages
39
Does silver solder really make that much difference?Has anyone built and test a pre with and without using silver solder?Also can you solder 66/44 rosin core solder to a pcb with silver traces?Never used silver solder before,just wondering if the cost is worth it?
 
i find it's easier to work with, and it makes a cleaner and brighter looking solder point. Silver is a better conductor, especially for audio, so I suppose it might sound better... but the actual silver content in "silver solder" is very low.
 
i use it all the time for stuff, it's not really any different except that it usually doesn't have lead in it. a good solder is a good solder no matter what it's made of(as long as it's also the correct formula for the application...) and good technique/habit will be worth more.
make sure the joint is clean before and after soldering, make sure the solder melted completely and freezes good and tight and you will be ok!
:guinness:
 
Silver bearing solder still has lead in it. It is usually only 2% silver. You probably won't benefit from it electrically. A good solder joint is the most important thing regardless of the solder used.

Silver solder is usually used in applications where a mechanical bond is necessary, rather than simply an electrical bond. It is used often in scale model building to connect metal parts, pipes, and fittings together. It is WAY strong compared to eutectic or 60/40 solder.

It still may have flux which can release fumes, and it still has lead.

plus it needs to get WAY hotter to melt, so you run a greater risk of damaging components due to overheating when using silver solder. Wire is particularly a pain because the insulation melts way before the solder!

Lead Free solder is usually tin and antimony. It is also often called "plumbers solder" and may also contain silver, but it is designed for applications where public safety is a concern (such as plumbing fixtures where water for human consumption may pass) as well as strength of mechanical bond. IT too has to get much hotter to melt, and is often used not with an iron but a butane torch. I have used it to make cables in a pinch, and it sucks trying to get the parts hot enouch to melt the solder before they are damaged.

63/37 is the best choice for electrical applications. It has a low melting temp, goes traight from a solid to a liquid and back again (no plastic phase), and allows you to apply as little heat to your work as possible. Electrically it is plenty conductive. (It probably makes your gear sound warm :grin: )

Look at some of the old "golden gear" and the blobs of solder you find inside. Now tell me how much difference you hink 2% silver will make to your signal integrity!

Shane
 
The only silver solder I know of is real silver used with flux. It requires heat from a torch as a jeweller would do. I've done this on my mirophone parts.

You could not use this process on pcb's. The torch would destroy the pcb.
 
I use WBT silver solder because it's the easiest and most pleasant solder I've ever worked with. It's a little expensive and I've never A/Bed it with regular solder in terms of sound. I wouldn't say it's particularly better sounding, but it sounds okay and I like working with it.

:guinness: :sam:
 
Back
Top