solid aluminium capacitor = tantalum?

GroupDIY Audio Forum

Help Support GroupDIY Audio Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Read your data sheet, especially the "solid MnO2 electrolyte" part, and then google tantalum capacitors.  Do some deductions, get some replacement tants, and get on with the music!

Mike
 
ricardo said:
...
from 1980  "Tants give a crackly, popcorn almost like 1/f noise or insufficient dither.  "
from 2015  "He found if C1 is a Tantalum, it is prone to whooshy LF noise"
[...]
If anyone has a theoretical explanation, I'm all ears.
...

1/f noise suggest current noise due to impurities or granularity rather than thermal noise due to ESR. Thermal noise is supposed to be white, the other 1/f as mentioned. As usual there is probably a bit of both but usually a frequency where them are the same level and the band of interest defines which one is the problem in each case. If we have the crossing at 1kHz the 1/f will predominate, if we have 30Hz the white will be the problem.

JS
 
sodderboy said:
Read your data sheet, especially the "solid MnO2 electrolyte" part, and then google tantalum capacitors.  Do some deductions, get some replacement tants, and get on with the music!

Mike

yup same electrolyte as tant but dielectric is aluminium oxide not tantalum oxide.

 
Important to remember the SPACE restrictions, or form factors, of electrolytics back in the classic Neve days. Tant was best space/capacitance value. And yes I see some lytics on my 283.
People seem to forget engineering is always compromise, and not every product decision is an audio decision.
Now film caps in EQ's, on a big console. There's some place I wouldn't expect anyone to notice, but they did (without being told any work had been performed), and we had to go back and replace all the replacement caps with stacked film replacement caps.
 
sodderboy said:
That's a tant cap.  Studer docs are made by humans.  Replace like with like and get on to the music.

The Studer multitrack manuals are full of misprints and language errors.  Prove me wrong.

Mike

The datasheet posted by Zam above has a picture of the cap which exactly matches the picture in the first post in this thread.
 
Back
Top