Well, the hum may be a clue. Mine's pretty quiet. Have you messed with C4 (the big trimmer cap that soldered onto the terminal strip)? I set mine to ~300pF before I installed it. Try cranking it CW (clockwise) if it's not all the way CW already.
So your situation is still that the meter has weak response and you don't get any noticable compression, right? You can get a strong and clean output without compression (PR at 0), right?
Did you try CJ's suggestion to disconnect one of the meter leads? <grasps handfull of straws>
Analog Packrat