jdbakker
Well-known member
jsteiger said:A couple of modules I have are TH with PTH's. Without desoldering something on them, I am not sure how oversized their component holes are. There is definitely a good complete joint on each side. How it was done is an educated guess. My educated guess is that they are pumping out as much product as they can which absolutely correlates to "you better only solder one side or you are fired"!! Time is money of course.
I would be surprised if any medium-to-large scale TH production in the last decade has been done by hand, given that wave soldering technology is relatively inexpensive and very mature. Maybe some smaller players in the Mainland or the Philippines still hand solder, but I doubt it.
jsteiger said:Anyhow, knowing that the big production assembly houses aren't doing it...is probably a good enough reason to do it!
The ones I've been involved with are mostly smaller specialist shops doing Hi-Rel proto and short-run work for industrial and military/aerospace projects. ICBW, but they've never given me the impression of rushing their staff, given that at the end of the day reliability and yield targets have to be met. (As with software bugs, it takes much longer to find and fix a marginal joint than to get it right the first time)
A few years back I was asked to hold a few EE-centric workshops for design students. As you might imagine, most had little to no soldering experience. Watching them work I got the strong impression that novice solderers are more likely to heat joints for too long. As too much heat can easily damage components and boards (through delamination), I would be hesitant to suggest any technique that encourages people to heat the joints even more. Soldering from the top has the added disadvantage of having the heat source closer to the component body, which can be especially bad for diodes and the like.
(I did notice that you only suggest to touch up after snipping the leads, and your staggered soldering procedure for the switches looks like a good idea. At the end of the day it's your guide, your decisions, and I'm not the one who gets to deal with board failures or returns. Your call.)
JDB.
[EDIT: grammar]