Do we really need relays for phantom/pad/polarity switching?

GroupDIY Audio Forum

Help Support GroupDIY Audio Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
emrr said:
John brings up a funny related tangent.  I do wish there was still market position for shaft extenders and flexible shafts.  I could use a lot of them for keeping pots closer to desired signal location, but there isn't much on the market at all.  And it's not as cheap as it should be.  I'm unaware of any available flexible shaft couplings. 

I've seen some clever or Rube Goldberg, depending on your perspective shaft extenders fashioned out of simple round or square stock and shrink tubing... I don't know how robust that would be long term (I would never use it in production).  This is quickly becoming academic as digital controlled analog parts can be put where they need to be and control parts where they need to be.

The days of huge PCBs with lots of unused area has passed. IMO

Some of the old gear designs were mechanical marvels with strings, and springs, and pulleys, and levers, and ....

JR

PS: Not to veer off into deep mechanical esoterica.. one of my mental exercises was to design a graphical interface for a parametric EQ. One of the beauties of simple graphic EQ is the visual representation of boost/cut and frequency by slider knob position.  My paragraphic used a boost cut slider (moving up/down) mounted to two frequency slider wiper tabss (moving left to right for lower to higher frequency. Finally the Q was a rotary control mounted like a knob on top of the boost/cut slider, with a rack and pinion contraption on it's knob to visually represent narrow or wide bandwidth. (this could also be accomplished by a spiral slot that reveals a wider background color as rotated. 

Obvious mechanical conflicts arise if frequency bands overlap, etc, and the cosmetic treatment of this is beyond my gadgetry skills.
 
Svart said:
good discussion.  personally I don't see a technical need for relays, it seems more psychological.

So, would you pay more for a device with a relay or would you rather save the money?

I started to use relays for aesthetic and technical reasons :)
Finding good switch (with proper contacts rated for low level switching) that also looks good on 2 or 3u case is a problem ime. So i buy cheap big switch, rated for higher currents, and control relay with it.
For 1u cases i have no problem finding technically correct and nice looking switches.
Some time ago i talked to Ioaudio about this and he was also having problems finding bigger switches for small signals.
Can anyone suggest a switch that would work well and look nice?

Miha
 
damn; here's the original flexible shaft maker, still in business:

http://www.sswhite.net/standard.htm
 
Can you suggest some big switches for small signals? Anyone else? I REALLY searched many sites and suppliers but couldn't really find something for this task. I think many others feel the same, at least when i asked everyone seemed to complain about it...
 
Back
Top