resistor value importance

GroupDIY Audio Forum

Help Support GroupDIY Audio Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

asm

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 6, 2004
Messages
520
Location
The Woodlands, TX - US -
im doing a 2x12 rotary switch on the ssl9k, some of the values are hard to find.

theres a 1% 15.8 and 1% 16.2 (im trying to get a 16.0)

or a 5% 16.0


which one should i get? why?

:thumb:
 
is that for the gain switch? I havent built one, but my guess would be that a difference of 200 ohms at that value is probably not going to make an incredibly off balanced step from the gain setting before it to the one after it. I would think that the degree to which it effects the taper could be worked around in daily use.

In the past I have approximated all kinds of values on gain switches, so long as you use the same value on all the switches in the box (ie, same approximation for left and right channel if there are two in the box) you should be fine. The taper is different, but so long as the taper of both units matches each other, for me thats what was really important.

of course if thats the last step on the switch and it starts to oscillate, forget all this...

dave
 
Why 1W? I don't understand? Digikey has all three of the values you mentioned in 1/4, 1/2W 1% and 5%, and mouser has the same. Or are trying to use stuff you have lying around? I would get the 16 5% and break out that ohmmeter. It is hard to say whether or not .2 ohms will make a difference without seeing this switch in the circuit.
 
[quote author="Family Hoof"]Why 1W? I don't understand? Digikey has all three of the values you mentioned in 1/4, 1/2W 1% and 5%, and mouser has the same. Or are trying to use stuff you have lying around? I would get the 16 5% and break out that ohmmeter. It is hard to say whether or not .2 ohms will make a difference without seeing this switch in the circuit.[/quote]

huh?

digikey doesnt have it, the 1/4w 5% yaegos go from 15.8 to 16.2

mouser has them, with a frickin 11 week lead time cause its on BO.

what effect will the slightly off numbers do to the gain? will it be stepped slightly instead of a smooth ramp?
 
> what effect will the slightly off numbers do to the gain? will it be stepped slightly instead of a smooth ramp?

If the plan calls for 16.0, and you use 16.2, no sound will come out at all, and the amplifier will burst from all the notes jammed up inside.

It's a switch. It is already stepped.

A single 10% error gives about a 1dB error. So you think you get 40, 45, 50, 55dB, you really get 40, 44, 50, 55dB. Or since we usually series resistors and use fairly large steps, maybe 40, 44, 49.5, 54.8dB.

One 10% error is not going to matter for recording.

Two "matched" stereo channels, one 10% off from the other, will show an image-shift. But lots of things cause 1dB errors, and you usually need a fine-balance trim somewhere between the act and the final master.

16.0 to 16.2 is a 1.25% or 0.11dB error. You can't hear that. Random 1% or even 5% errors in your whole resistor string average out to small 0.5dB errors.

The way to get in trouble is to be 10% out in the same direction on every step. Then instead of 5dB steps 20 25 30... 60 you might go 20 24 28... 52, and wind up 8 dB short of what you expected.

Use a 17 ohm resistor, if that's what you got.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top