True RMS vs averaging DMM

GroupDIY Audio Forum

Help Support GroupDIY Audio Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
The 187 is by far the most power hungry meter Ive owned , I usually replace the batteries every few months .
I believe the 77IV has now been discontinued by Fluke , replaced with the 170 series .
Settling time on the 187 on low AC ranges is longer than the 77IV ,but maybe thats due to the RMS .
Ive heard quite a few mentions of the 8060a from studio guys here , having the db scale is a huge benefit for checking audio gear quickly.
The Agilent U1253A battery lasts around 4-10 hours! this is due to the fact that it uses an OLED screen, it looks beautiful though, the designers decided to use a 9V rechargable battery, not a good choice. I haven't seen any meter with less battery time than this, ever.... Plus, the screen has a limited life time, over time (whether you use it or not) it becomes dark up to the point that it just fails, Agilent/Keysight wont replace it nor will they offer the spare parts, the only available option is a guy from China who sells them at TaoBao, I had to replace mine.
 
The Agilent U1253A battery lasts around 4-10 hours! this is due to the fact that it uses an OLED screen, it looks beautiful though, the designers decided to use a 9V rechargable battery, not a good choice.
Really bad design because the meter is down when recharging. I gave up on that fast and use a regular toxic landfill type.
 
Really bad design because the meter is down when recharging. I gave up on that fast and use a regular toxic landfill type.
How much do they last? I was planning on doing it but seems like I would need an endless amount of batteries....
 
How much do they last? I was planning on doing it but seems like I would need an endless amount of batteries....
Those Energizer Industrial ones are pretty impressive. My brother in law loaned me an automobile scanner from his work , which hadn't been used in forever, the terminals inside the scanner actually rusted apart, and the batteries were still like new and tested as . Not sure how long they can supply the juice though....
 
How much do they last? I was planning on doing it but seems like I would need an endless amount of batteries....
That’s why it became the country cabin meter…

They should have sent it with two rechargeable batteries and a wall charger. Having it charge the battery through the probe ports is idiotic.
 
If I ever have a dacha, absolutely no voltages allowed.
Mike
It’s two garden sheds. I charge batteries so there is light for 5 days. The propane lights in the other cabin are a PITA. After 5 years of lugging batteries I’m getting real electricity. I’m waiting for Nat Grid to install a pole. Then it’s a 450 foot run in a trench to the cabins.
 
Have you ever considered solar ?
It’s heavily forested and in the winter there is very little sun. If it is supposed to supply heat in the winter I’d have to clear a lot of land and it would be hugely expensive. Even in the summer there can be little sun. It’s almost a rain forest.
 
I got a small solar panel years ago (12 watt) , in winter I use it to keep my mower battery in good condition ,connects directly across the battery and pulses quicker or slower depending on the intensity of the light .
Its useful for car batteries too , you place the panel on the back window and plug the unit into the lighter socket .
The small panel cost around 10 euros and in the end I got more than 10 years useage from that battery .

I bought a UNi-T 171b before I got the Fluke , I though initially the rechargable battery was a good plan .
Like the Keysight it charges through the probe ports with the switch in the off position , its not a regular 9v cell but a specific two cell lipo with a jst connector , I much prefer the Fluke with standard AA(187) or 9v cells (77IV), if you want rechargeable you do the charge externally from the meter .

Maybe you could have installed a solar panel up in the canopy to gather more light Paul , never the less clearing an area in the vicinity of your cabin might be a good plan to prevent the chances of fire during the hotter summer months .

Ive recently got myself an army style 'basha' shelter for getting out of the rat race every once in a while , Ive used a pair of telescopic hiking poles (with a removable spike installed at the handle end) , bungee cords and a small pulley in each corner , its set up and water proof in only minutes . I was also able to get several other nice accessories for it from my local army surplus , artic grade sleeping bag with washable liner , insect net and bivi bag and I even picked up a really nice 55L rucksack for 5 euros from a thrift store . Its way more versatile than a tent and can be set up in many different configurations depending on usage and territory . Another plus point is the basha sheet itself is modular ,enabling two or more sheets to be clipped together to make a larger shelter .
I got a led light with motion detection sensor and seperate solar panel , that is easily mounted either inside or outside the tent depending on what you need . I'm still testing in the back garden for now ,gradually adding the various pieces of kit I need . I did find some usefull remote controlled battery powered led lamps, they have RGB so you can mix the colours and they even come with a small keyfob remote , very handy for locating your hide in dense undergrowth , especially if you have a few beers down the hatch returning from the pub late at night .
Im really having a lot of fun with this , I cant wait to try it out .
 
Last edited:
with 19 kHz and 20 kHz which one is the carrier?

[edit- back in the 70s when I converted my heathkit SMPTE IMD to work with 19/20kHz I used the simple average meter in the Heathkit. I guess this makes all my benchwork back then suspect? :unsure: [/edit]

JR

The carrier is the sum of the two.
If 19/20 kHz are at 1:1 ratios the power sum is +3 dB.
I measured the average level, on multiple average-responding meters, to be about 1.4 dB lower when compared to the RMS-responding Fluke and RMS-responding FFT measurements which correctly show a +3 dB sum.

I don't think the 1.4 dB difference makes your bench work suspect.

I like Fluke the 8050A and also own an 8060 I used for field service.

Fluke_8050A_Collection.jpg


The pic is from when I had four, I now have five 8050As in my measurement stack.

One interesting trick I learned is that it can do dB measurements in the DC measurement mode.
For really accurate attenuator measurement I use DC as the stimulus.
The DC dB measurements come in handy.

The 8060s LCD display can often be repaired by cleaning the electro-tin-plated PC board contact to Zebra strip elastomeric connector "interface."
I use a dry Q-tip to burnish the PC board fingers.
When those are cleaned missing segments on the display will often come back to life.
I bought a replacement LCD years ago and never used it because I was able to refurbish the old one.

The 8050As are inexpensive on eBay and usually have two problems: Bad LCDs or NiCd batteries.
The batteries are easily-replaced and the unit won't run without them.
 
It’s two garden sheds. I charge batteries so there is light for 5 days. The propane lights in the other cabin are a PITA. After 5 years of lugging batteries I’m getting real electricity. I’m waiting for Nat Grid to install a pole. Then it’s a 450 foot run in a trench to the cabins.
OT but I hope they have a transformer in stock to install.
I have a friend in rural OK who has been waiting months for his utility to get delivery of a pole pig.
The back-order times are crazy long.
 
OT but I hope they have a transformer in stock to install.
I have a friend who has been waiting months for his utility to get delivery of a pole pig.
The back-order times are crazy long.
They said 4-8 weeks. I sent the final paperwork in yesterday.
 
Here is a Quora type question intended especially for those members who think that DIYers do not need oscilloscopes, but that a DMM is sufficient.
The linear power supply consists of a transformer, a full-bridge rectifier, a capacitor and a 7812 regulator. The regulator needs a minimum ratio of Vin-Vout=3V to work properly.
Average DMM in DC position measures 17V at the reg input. What is the maximum voltage that can be measured in the AC position at the reg input for the regulator to work correctly?

View attachment 96514

"Maximum Voltage" ?
Do you mean "Minimum Voltage" there ?
The maximum would be whatever circuit can withstand without something overheating and being damaged or wrt the 7812 cutting out.
 
"Maximum Voltage" ?
Do you mean "Minimum Voltage" there ?
The maximum would be whatever circuit can withstand without something overheating and being damaged or wrt the 7812 cutting out.
Ha, I was already thinking of deleting that post :). It is a question of measuring the maximum permissible AC voltage (ripple) modulated to DC.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top