I agree. However, I have also cleaned two (expensive very nice) capsules before. I didn’t want to. They belonged to me and in both cases, I accidentally spit on them while either repairing or installing something, can’t remember. It was among the dumbest things I have ever done, but do enough DIY over the years and eventually, you too can (and probably will) do something almost as dumb as me. The good news is, after cotton swab/distilled water with a very, very light touch and very steady hands (my line of work involves a lot of small parts and fine motor skills), I noticed absolutely zero difference in the way that they sound as well as their performance over time. Granted, I was very careful, and am generally very good in the workshop/diy studio/instrument parts repair area, and I go very slow and think about things a lot before I do them, so someone else’s outcome may be different, but I will go out on a limb and say that in the worst case scenario where you’ve either unfortunately caused or located a problem on a capsule that warrants cleaning, it is possible and you can do it with success if you know what you’re doing. I cannot pick out the capsules I have by ear comparing the ones I have cleaned to the ones I haven’t.
Knock on wood, I won’t have to ever do this again. I didn’t mean to or want to do it in the first place. I’m just saying that in the spirit of diy, other than the unfortunate outcome of the OP’s situation, I haven’t heard very many horror stories.
Neumann published a cleaning method that actually involved isopropyl alcohol to clean capsules at one time. Personally I would not use a solvent on my capsule. But that’s Neumann telling you you can do that! I don’t feel like searching around for it, but I saw the published maintenance card with the Neumann insignia on it with my own eyes. Maybe someone here has it and can post it. Again, I’m not recommending it. But I read the process and it was simple. I subbed the alcohol for distilled water.
Basically though, I’d tend to agree with Mr. Bock and Mr. Josephson, and they definitely know what they are talking about when it comes to microphones. Two of the best & brightest. Especially Josephson in this subjective area, as they actually make their own capsules, to my knowledge. I believe Bock was having Huan manufacture custom capsules for his mics when they were still in production.
I actually have a Bock 47. I opened it up and looked inside once. I couldn’t ID the origin of his K47 by sight. Looked very nice though. Interestingly, it’s just the Oliver ef800 circuit, and a Cinemag u47 style trafo on the output. Cheap $20 Ultron tube inside. I replaced it with a Telefunken, and it sounds better to my ears. I like that mic and got a really good deal on it used, but after having built some tube mics myself now and realizing that guys like Bock are just using the same circuits we have access to here, I’d never spend that kind of money on a clone, or even a Neumann reissue, ever again. When I bought the Bock used, long before I replaced the tube, some things like the grounding adhesive on the head-basket had actually already failed, it was humming, yet still under warranty and he kindly repaired it for me. They did a great job at Bock, it’s sounded perfect ever since and that was over 5 years ago. The Neumann capsules sound amazing, but dude, Soliloqueen’s are up there sonically, too. Really awesome capsules. I no longer see the need to spend high dollars on Neumann LDC’s unless you have money to burn and just want to impress clients.
Sorry for the slight thread derailment. I get carried away with this subject… Love mics.