Last night I managed to finish building and calibrating my Rev D after a few snags! The unit sounds fantastic! So happy with it. Many props to mnats, Hairball, and all the good folks on this forum. I didn't even have to post my questions because all the answers were in here waiting for me to read them.
I wanted to share a couple things that could be of some use to current and/or future builders that was not totally clear to me when starting...
For my build I used the 2N5088 in all available locations (Q5, Q7, Q8, Q9, Q10, Q12, Q13). Let me tell you, do spend some time checking and double checking and triple checking the pin configuration on these components before you stuff them in the boards! I first mistakenly populated these comments improperly and I spent the better part of 24 hours trying to figure out what was wrong with my build when I powered it up. Somewhere along the way I was misinformed in either in a post on the forum or I misread somewhere or on the datasheet... who knows. Upon start-up, I blew R32, was blowing fuses left and right, I was not reading proper voltages at the test points provided in the PDF on mnats FAQ page, couldn't cal the unit for squat, and some other wackiness. I had already checked my power supply and it was very stable so I ruled that out early on. It was looking quite grim for a second but I hung in there had an inclination that there was a somewhat simple solution that would singlehandedly fix many, if not all of these problems, which would eventually be true. I wondered how so many voltages could be wrong?! All of my solder joints and wiring was legit... something was wrong!
I read in my research that a common reason for R32 to burn up is incorrect output transformer wiring... this was not true in my case. It was properly wired via the transformer wire colors, the PCB label, and the mnats instructions. Ultimately the reason my 1176 was being dragged through hell was because the 5088 were not properly installed. So, if you're burning R32's and you're using 5088's, check your pinouts!
The in-line transistor holes for the above listed Q's are for an ECB config and the triangular shape nearest to the left (leaving alone the far right hole) is for an EBC config.
Just to verify for 5088 users, the extra pad on the top of the mounting hole set for each transistor is a redundant base pad for use with an EBC config, like the 5088. This means you can use this pad in conjunction with the two pads DIRECTLY below it (E and C). So, you will be mounting the transistor in a triangular shape and will NOT be using the pad farthest to the right (looking down reading from left to right). I went ahead and tested continuity between the in-line base pad on the far right, and the alternate base pad on top and sure enough they were connected. After I found this out, the light went off and it all made perfect sense! I wasn't exactly sure how to seat this transistor in the pads before this since the board wasn't marked (only a graphic shape). So, if this extra pad wasn't there, one would have to shrink tube the C and B transistor leads and essentially criss-cross them to get them in the proper pads, which would be a pain in the @$$ and if not done properly would cause shorting and I'm sure would start blowing $h!t up. No good. So, thank you mnats for this convenience!
After seating these transistors properly my voltages lined up, the machine passed clean audio, compressed, the meter worked, I could cal it, and it sounded amazing!
As of now I've not been blowing fuses anymore... I was originally confused by this because my +30DC and -10DC rails were stable from the start, even with the transistors in wrong. Perhaps it may start happening again regardless? I'm not sure at this point. I'm using 250mA slow blow fuses. I may switch to 400mA or even 500mA if it starts happening again. In an earlier post I read that some guys were getting inrush peaks at and above 500mA. Also, when these fuses blew, I really had no indication they had blown on me. There was no brief start up and then die off... it was, turn the unit off, ok, good... now turn it back on.... oh... nothing.... weird.
In retrospect, I'm glad I was forced to work diligently in figuring out my issue and fixing it. It would have been great to fire the thing up, cal it, and rock and roll right off the bat but that just wasn't the case. Now I know the circuit way more than I would have and I learned a lot of other things along the way, too. In a way, I'm glad.
Word to the wise, pre-measure your components, check check check your transistor pinouts if you're using the 5088's, and DON'T GIVE UP ON YOUR BUILD if you're having issues! Too much good info on this forum to let your project sit on the shelf. I'm working on three of these builds right now so I can go ahead and finish the other two for my buddy! I'm hopeful now that I've been put through the 1176 ringer, finishing these other two will be a snap. Can't wait to build more in the future!
Wes