Hi All-
Thanks for the help so far. A quick update. I reflowed all the joints again, then desoldered, removed and tested the Tpad and replaced it (not fun, wow). I checked for bridged connections as best I could with a multi meter and triple checked the output transformer wiring and component values and placement. No luck yet.
I did learn to use my scope and signal generator though, so even if this pre never works I've gained a bit of knowledge.
Here's what my scope shows, and please feel free to correct my beginner mistakes.
I connect the scope and signal generators ground wires to pin one on the card connector. With the other lead of the signal generator I inject a 1K sin wave at R3. The scope probe shows the sin wav makes it all the way to the Opamp with no issues. Post Op amp the amplitude of the sin wave grows as I expected. With the phase switch out the sin wave shows up at the red lead of the output transformer and not at the orange, phase switch in shows the opposite. The mute switch eliminates the sin wave at both the orange and red leads. Unless I'm missing something this all looks good.
Where it starts to look funny is with the phase switch out the sin wav shows up at the Brown, Green and Black leads at about half the amplitude of the red but the blue lead shows a slightly higher amplitude than the red lead. The phase switch moves the larger amplitude sin wav to the black lead. The Tpad has no effect on the sin at the green or brown leads but both the black and blue lead's sin waves are slightly higher amplitude at the extremes of the Tpad and slightly lower amplitude at the center of it's travel.
At pin 2 of the edge connector you get a large amplitude sin wav with Tpad fully up. As you turn the Tpad down the sin diminishes to zero amplitude and then back up to half amplitude when the Tpad is all the way down. Pin 4 on the edge connector shows a similar phenomenon except the amplitude is not as high as pin 2 when the Tpad is all the way up and it doesn't diminish all the way to zero amplitude. If you reverse the phase switch Pin 2 does the same thing but opposite and pin 4 does the same thing except with a large amplitude sin wav.
I am now stuck, thanks so much to anyone that has any ideas. If anyone can confirm I'm using the scope right I'm thinking I'll post a few photos of how to hook things up and trace the signal. Might be a useful post for some other guys.
-mike