OK so your comment on the line in confused me.
Youre normally using the LINE input, you have the issue; and you used the re-amp box to plug a line signal into the mic input (just trying to clarify for my own understanding) If thats correct, break out the probe and scope and start tracing. If you think its dropping everything below 250, put a 100hz signal through and trace to see where the signal goes bad or gets drastically lower on the scope, then reference the schematic in that area. Colin did a great job of "departmentalizing" the different areas of this circuit in the color book.
Just out of curiosity, does the polarity switch seem to make any difference if switched? (and does it do what its supposed to?)