spica said:
...I have signal on the SC side of the resistor but nothing on the VCA side... however, wouldn't I have to have signal there to be seeing signal at the output?...
Signal voltage - no. VCAs are current-in / current-out devices.
The threshold pot swings the voltage at Pin 2 of the TL072 from +3V to -3V. Seems to be working.
Seems to be not working. Opamps inverting input Pin 2 is a summing node at virtual ground. You might have a broken TL072 or pin 3 is missing connection to 0V (solder missing or chip leg not in socket?). Your +/-3V further implies, you left out the 47k between ccw side of threshold pot and +12V. Look out for shorts or wrong part values. If you have fitted a trimmer for meter calibration, watch out for trimmers initial setting about centered.