Hello all!
So, I've been down in this rabbit hole with ya for a couple of months. That is, I got into DIY microphones a few months ago and have been learning a lot. I'm no electronics designer, even though I can follow a schematic well, so please do forgive my ignorance at times.
With that out of the way, I took the liberty to re-read this whole forum and write down some questions and/or ideas or pieces of knowledge I've stumbled up, which I hope could aid in the development.
Firstly, I would like to ask
@Tubetec if you could ever so kindly send me a copy of the Microphone engineering handbook by M. Gayford? It's truly an elusive book and I haven't been able to find it in digital anywhere, except your chapter 8. I've been enjoying microphone literature recently and it has often been very enlightening.
@shot, if you haven't sorted out your noise-inconsistency problem still.. If it's not caused by circuitry, maybe it's a problem with the quality of components? Have you personally verified all parts work? I've made a habit to do check every component, since I built my first DJJules pimped alice with a counterfeit PF5102 from ebay that arrived dead-on-arrival, and lost two days troubleshooting (and learning JFET theory. And problems with counterfeit transistors).
Also, I had the dumbest thing happen to my whilst recording, just the worst case of the spontaneous hums/noises - turns out it was a single loose strand of copper wire from the cable's shielding touching pin 2 or 3 inside the connector jack - a trim and a quick solder later all is good, but maybe it's something random like that then? Please do let us know if you have already found out the cause.
@rogs, I have to commend you for everything you have done on this project, it has been a delight to follow your progress, but also your website, which is extremely well done. I have plans to take inspiration from your website when I will be making my own, hopefully soon enough.
You certainly know more about what is going on in the electronics then I do, so I wanted to ask you if you could shed some light on.
-
Coils/crystal. I ordered the Spectrum 5u3HH coils and some cheapo K87 china capsules, and all the capsules tested in the 42-52pF range, which got me concerned at first, but the microphone worked honestly extremely well with the capsule, within 2pF for C4, and 10MHz crystal.
I did try out to swap out the crystals, I do believe there were mentions of Ruud using even a 12MHz with success. Placing the mic between my headphones playing a 1kHz tone, 52pF LDC capsule + 51pf C4, Behrry UMC404HD input gain set the same, both T1 and T2 tuned after each swap to max, I got:
10,00MHz, -42dB
10,70MHz, -36dB
11,06MHz, -28dB
So, obviously there is an increase in sensitivity, but I still haven't gotten into the realm of microphone testing.
There was a mention of a C3 'SOT' (also what does that stand for?) compensating for capsules with less capacitance, but it adds noise then, right? I also think someone mentioned that even the lower capacitance capsules will works, just will be somewhat less sensitive with no more extra noise? Speaking of noise...
-
Distortion. What software did you use to determine your distortion (THD%) for RF.AMX10 and competitors? The other day I was trying to learn what capacitors are for, following this neat article:
Practical Test & Measurement - Stop Worrying About Coupling Capacitors!
I made the tester and my goal was to measure THD in different types of capacitors, with the intention to prove or disprove the polyester vs polypropylene cap noise superiority. However, I myself own a UMC404HD which is my first audio interface and one I'm extremely happy (especially for the price), but I couldn't get THD under 0,2%, no matter what I tried with the components, tester or inputs, but then realized it's definitely the UMC404's preamp (apparently a Midas preamp ain't a Midas PRO preamp).
Rogs, have to tried to measure distortion with your UMC404HD? Their website doesn't specify THD levels (like Scarlett does) for the model, and I know Sound Devices are quality stuff. I don't know if the problem is in the tester I built or the limitations of a really-affordable sound card, because I would definitely like to give distortion testing a try.
I used REW to try and analyze cap distortion, but THD would always be way higher (THD 0,1-0,2% for caps assumed to be 0,01%), except for ceramics, which were about 0,2% - ceramics are definitely not recommended for audio signal paths.
Apparently, you could use REW to test microphone preamps (without the capsule) for distortion in this method. I'm not sure how, and haven't tried it, but maybe it could be useful in seeing where the problem lies, without the capsule.
-
Padding. Is there a relationship, like equation, connecting the RP1 value to how much dB it will pad? I installed:
RP1 2,2k and got about 15db padding
RP2 1,0k and got about 20dB padding
but I didn't measure them too precisely, I will have to redo those tests.
I implemented Khron's idea to put the pins and the small jumper to act as a pad switch, but I put in a row of 4 pins instead, so that the jumper doesn't swivel when only on one pin (visible in the attached photo; padding is set off). Working great so far.
Speaking of which,
@Khron, thank you for your PCB design contributions! I actually learned new things from your design, I'll send you a PM when I prepare questions and ideas about the PCB's design, and hopefully I can help contribute too.
-
Multipattern. Rogs, you mentioned you don't think multipattern is feasible, but specifically in this, one oscillator design, right? Is there any point in perhaps making two oscillators run one dual-membrane capsule, connected to one JFET? I do believe there were mentions there might be interference from the other oscillator, but I'll be willing to test that out if you hook me up with a schematic. Alternatively, that is solved by using a housing bigger than a BM800 (i.e. I just got a fake U87 mic, and it definitely has enough real estate to ensure there is no interference.) I accidently ordered a three-wired capsule(front memb., back memb., with connected backplates) instead of a single membrane, so I'm invested now
I think this is more or less everything I had on mind. And please do let me know if I got something wrong.
P.S. I ordered the royal purple PCBs from JLCPCB. I adore how nice it looks and I've been enjoying how it sounds.