Spencerleehorton
Well-known member
I’ll change the 12ax7 tubes first before I start taking things apart.
Last edited:
JTM45 Build with various output tubes and GZ34/Solid State Rectifier
- Thread starter Spencerleehorton
- Start date
Help Support GroupDIY Audio Forum:
Spencerleehorton
Well-known member
Took all tubes out apart from GZ34 and checked voltages, B+ 460v.
Turned on standby and dropped a bit to 457v.
Then put OT in and 12ax7s.
Power on B+ 460v as soon as standby turned on B+ drops to 403v!!
Bias was set at 43ma.
I then dropped bias to 36ma (el34)
This then put B+ to 414v from 403v
Checked out other voltages across the tubes and although they looked low it all looked consistent.
I wonder whether the GZ34 is damaged?
Turned on standby and dropped a bit to 457v.
Then put OT in and 12ax7s.
Power on B+ 460v as soon as standby turned on B+ drops to 403v!!
Bias was set at 43ma.
I then dropped bias to 36ma (el34)
This then put B+ to 414v from 403v
Checked out other voltages across the tubes and although they looked low it all looked consistent.
I wonder whether the GZ34 is damaged?
Spencerleehorton
Well-known member
I think what I will try is to revert back to the original way that B+ was connected and see if it is the same.
Spencerleehorton
Well-known member
Yep same problem, choke is fine so it must be gz34, so I’ve ordered a new one.
Accelerator
Well-known member
@Spencerleehorton
Man, ride out this shitty Radial 100 watt Output transformer and put in a proper & correct Output transformer for the tubes that you would like to use and at least use a matched pair of Output tubes …If you would like to use a matched pair of EL34 / KT77 / 6CA7 Output Tubes, you have to install a Drake type JTM50 3200 ~ 3600 (A-A*) 50 watt Output transformer and you will have nearly 50 watt output…
If you would like to use a matched pair of KT66 Output Tubes, you will have to install a Radiospades type JTM45 8000 (A-A*) 35 watt Output transformer and you will have nearly 35 watt output…
The whole “Spartan spirit” of the Marshall 35watt JTM45 amp. it is NOT for you to makes this Grande cheapie B.S. with this Shitty & Uncorrected Radial 100 watt Output transformer in this amp., and then to add the one B.S. after the other B.S., like the idiotic dangerous & cheapie B.S. with the 6P3P output tubes, then the B.S. with the P.PI.M.V. to tame down your higher wattage that comes from your Shitty & Uncorrected Radial 100 watt Output transformer with your unmatched pair of your EL34 tube, and then the B.S. with the Dual bias to matched your unmatched pair of your EL34 Output tubes, and then the B.S. with the Fx loop and the list of your B.S. goes on and on and on, asking continues like an attention slut for someone to helps you or to save you from your continues and dangerous B.S.…
Before you make any another new B.S. and asking continues like an attention slut for someone to help you from your continues and dangerous B.S. make yourself a favor to educate yourself by spending a little bit of your time to read this book:
Designing Tube Preamps for Guitar and Bass, 2nd edition by Merlin Blencowe
I don’t care, I don’t give a F*kk and I don’t have any economical or any other effort if you buy this book, if you download this book by a “pirate” site, if you read it in your public library, if you steal it from a book shelf or whatever else…
You MUST READ THIS BOOK because ‘till this time you are an Uneducated and Dangerous Newbie for yourself and for everybody near you and for the whole DIY-er Community…
By the way, like any Marshall amp. lover here & out there I have to tell you, that the Marshall 35watt JTM45 amp., it is not a “polymorphic” B.S. amp. like any “Mesa Boogie”-like amp., with all of these “add ons” and “add ons” and “add ons” to mods and mods and mods to ruin the whole sound…
The “Marshall Roar” sound it is like a malt whisky that you drinking it straight, you don’t ruin it…
Spencerleehorton
Well-known member
I’m going to ignore most of that as this is a learning exercise for me and may, I hope, help anyone else who may have similar issues.
I have reverted to the tube town schematic and redone the wiring as per that.
Still getting the drop from 465v on B+ to about 414v when standby is turned on but will change the GZ34 and see if improves.
Have also reverted to one bias pot and getting 37ma on each OT, just wanted to see if the bias wiring was the problem.
Will take out the third extra 10k on the last node of B+ and see if any change.
Mains txf does only seem to get a little warm now but only tested for about 20-30 minutes.
I have reverted to the tube town schematic and redone the wiring as per that.
Still getting the drop from 465v on B+ to about 414v when standby is turned on but will change the GZ34 and see if improves.
Have also reverted to one bias pot and getting 37ma on each OT, just wanted to see if the bias wiring was the problem.
Will take out the third extra 10k on the last node of B+ and see if any change.
Mains txf does only seem to get a little warm now but only tested for about 20-30 minutes.
If people weren't interested in helping you with your build they wouldn't comment 187 times on this thread. Don't be discouraged by Accelerator's attacking language.
Running mismatched tubes is not a problem, just not ideal.
Mismatched OT can work
Effects loop is ok if that's what you like - Marshall does it
Master volume is fine if that's what you like - Marshall does it (very common mod on vintage amps)
Building an amp with different output tubes is fine - Everyone does it
The trick is to know the changes you need to make to make it work, and that's what we're working toward. You might not get the classic Marshall tone with your combo, but it's not anyone else' amp but yours.
Cutting down on mismatches and parts that we're unfamiliar with would help troubleshooting and cut down on variables, but if the OTX and PTX are known to be good and you have datasheets for them, the problems are all solvable.
The valve wizard website is great source.
Built my first jtm45/100 off of info from uncle Doug, valve wizard, el34 forum and the Marshall plexi forum
That voltage drop seems fine, and wouldn't be a problem for the right transformer. You can calculate exactly how much current is getting pulled across the mains transformer with the voltage drop and your last filter resistor before the output transformer. This would tell you if you're in spec and you can look elsewhere for problems and not have to replace a gz34. GZ34 drops voltage on its own. There are charts for this on the web.
You're obviously not uneducated or dangerous - the amp sounds good and the guts look good. Troubleshooting is hard, especially when you're learning.
I think it would be most helpful here to do what you're doing and stick with one schematic and modify it one step at a time. Maybe it's time for a post to refresh everybody here on what exactly we're working on, and what the current problems are that you're trying to resolve, with up-to-date schematics.
Once it's working like the schemo, then we can better help you with mods
Running mismatched tubes is not a problem, just not ideal.
Mismatched OT can work
Effects loop is ok if that's what you like - Marshall does it
Master volume is fine if that's what you like - Marshall does it (very common mod on vintage amps)
Building an amp with different output tubes is fine - Everyone does it
The trick is to know the changes you need to make to make it work, and that's what we're working toward. You might not get the classic Marshall tone with your combo, but it's not anyone else' amp but yours.
Cutting down on mismatches and parts that we're unfamiliar with would help troubleshooting and cut down on variables, but if the OTX and PTX are known to be good and you have datasheets for them, the problems are all solvable.
The valve wizard website is great source.
Built my first jtm45/100 off of info from uncle Doug, valve wizard, el34 forum and the Marshall plexi forum
That voltage drop seems fine, and wouldn't be a problem for the right transformer. You can calculate exactly how much current is getting pulled across the mains transformer with the voltage drop and your last filter resistor before the output transformer. This would tell you if you're in spec and you can look elsewhere for problems and not have to replace a gz34. GZ34 drops voltage on its own. There are charts for this on the web.
You're obviously not uneducated or dangerous - the amp sounds good and the guts look good. Troubleshooting is hard, especially when you're learning.
I think it would be most helpful here to do what you're doing and stick with one schematic and modify it one step at a time. Maybe it's time for a post to refresh everybody here on what exactly we're working on, and what the current problems are that you're trying to resolve, with up-to-date schematics.
Once it's working like the schemo, then we can better help you with mods
Spencerleehorton
Well-known member
I’m now using the tube town schematic, I have changed the wiring of the B+ as per the schematic minus the 48k resistor across the standby switch.
The 2 x 100R I have left off the GZ34.
Mains txf tests as 2 x 337 / 336vac
, 6.18vac on heaters and 4.88vac on heater of GZ34.
B+ is 465v
Standby switch is 414v
8.2k = 317v
10k = 250v
10k = 220v
Mains transformer get to about 40C after about 30 minutes then I turn off as I get volume drops.
Michael at modulus amplification who made the mains transformer, choke and I do have a output transformer from him but he has said not to use it with EL34 due to him using smaller gauge wire so he could fit all the winds on there.
But has said I can send the transformer back and he will test and send me another one.
I have tested without tubes and just gz34 and voltages all look normal.
Then added back in OT and tested again and still get drop to 414v once standby is turned on.
I have ordered another GZ34 to see how voltages look and good to have a back up anyways.
I might take out the gz34 and put in some diodes which will put me at about 475v after the bridge rectifier and then test again.
Maybe an option to have this switched. The benefit would be if in the future the GZ34 had any problems I can just switch to solid state.
The 2 x 100R I have left off the GZ34.
Mains txf tests as 2 x 337 / 336vac
, 6.18vac on heaters and 4.88vac on heater of GZ34.
B+ is 465v
Standby switch is 414v
8.2k = 317v
10k = 250v
10k = 220v
Mains transformer get to about 40C after about 30 minutes then I turn off as I get volume drops.
Michael at modulus amplification who made the mains transformer, choke and I do have a output transformer from him but he has said not to use it with EL34 due to him using smaller gauge wire so he could fit all the winds on there.
But has said I can send the transformer back and he will test and send me another one.
I have tested without tubes and just gz34 and voltages all look normal.
Then added back in OT and tested again and still get drop to 414v once standby is turned on.
I have ordered another GZ34 to see how voltages look and good to have a back up anyways.
I might take out the gz34 and put in some diodes which will put me at about 475v after the bridge rectifier and then test again.
Maybe an option to have this switched. The benefit would be if in the future the GZ34 had any problems I can just switch to solid state.
Well, I can't even chalk your devastating language to you not being a native English speaker. You have enough command of it to be perfectly heard.
Your words are deliberately rude and insulting, and clearly infringing rule #4.
https://groupdiy.com/threads/groupdiy-rules-read-before-posting-in-any-of-the-forums.6650/
Although not specifically addressed in the group's rules, improper language is not encouraged (euphemism). If you think this helps you to carry your message, think twice, it does not make you look good.
I don't think it's a good idea to use power transformer bolts for ground connections, esp. the safety ground (which should be on its own and not shared with anything else). Might want to check out this thread:
https://ampgarage.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=37456
re: the weird harmonizer stuff, it's generally referred to as "ghosting" and can have various causes such as the guitar, speaker(s), and (maybe the more obvious?) residual B+ ripple modulating the signal plus lack of hum cancellation (I guess this is "common mode rejection"?) of the push-pull output. Some people think it's cool if at a small degree, but for others it drives them crazy. Check out a couple of these threads:
https://ampgarage.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=32742
https://ampgarage.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=31923&start=45
(After reading through the 13 page "JTM45 rectifier question" thread (phew), I think one of the problems was a build (implementation) issue (maybe more than one), where the wire carrying AC to the bias circuit is twisted together with a B+ line wire going to a filter/de-coupling cap (which is part of the signal loop).
In that amp garage thread the ghosting issue was resolved by adding another stage of filtering (which would obviously reduce ripple), but someone asks the question (on page 9 of the thread), "Why is such extreme filtering required to make this amp behave when a 5F6-A, essentially the same circuit, works fine at 450V using Rectifier-40uF(plates)-4H-20uF(screens) ??", so I tend to think the implementation was not quite up to par.
I remember a very old thread years ago on ampage (BBS), where someone with a (model) 1962 "Bluesbreaker" (basically the same thing as JTM45 but a combo which includes tremolo) was having issues after having the amp retrogressed to the more early vintage circuit (which has less filtering--the reiss. had all 50uFs). One of the things mentioned which apparently improved on the ghosting was shielding the AC carrying wire going to the bias circuit (the chassis is wider in the Bluesbreaker and that wire is run a long way along the back panel then up toward the PCB).
To me, the Fender 5F6-A bias circuit (for that AC wire) looks better than the Marshall JTM45 (one part where they deviated a little bit from the Fender layout) since it's further away from other stuff and short.
https://ampgarage.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=37456
re: the weird harmonizer stuff, it's generally referred to as "ghosting" and can have various causes such as the guitar, speaker(s), and (maybe the more obvious?) residual B+ ripple modulating the signal plus lack of hum cancellation (I guess this is "common mode rejection"?) of the push-pull output. Some people think it's cool if at a small degree, but for others it drives them crazy. Check out a couple of these threads:
https://ampgarage.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=32742
https://ampgarage.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=31923&start=45
(After reading through the 13 page "JTM45 rectifier question" thread (phew), I think one of the problems was a build (implementation) issue (maybe more than one), where the wire carrying AC to the bias circuit is twisted together with a B+ line wire going to a filter/de-coupling cap (which is part of the signal loop).
In that amp garage thread the ghosting issue was resolved by adding another stage of filtering (which would obviously reduce ripple), but someone asks the question (on page 9 of the thread), "Why is such extreme filtering required to make this amp behave when a 5F6-A, essentially the same circuit, works fine at 450V using Rectifier-40uF(plates)-4H-20uF(screens) ??", so I tend to think the implementation was not quite up to par.
I remember a very old thread years ago on ampage (BBS), where someone with a (model) 1962 "Bluesbreaker" (basically the same thing as JTM45 but a combo which includes tremolo) was having issues after having the amp retrogressed to the more early vintage circuit (which has less filtering--the reiss. had all 50uFs). One of the things mentioned which apparently improved on the ghosting was shielding the AC carrying wire going to the bias circuit (the chassis is wider in the Bluesbreaker and that wire is run a long way along the back panel then up toward the PCB).
To me, the Fender 5F6-A bias circuit (for that AC wire) looks better than the Marshall JTM45 (one part where they deviated a little bit from the Fender layout) since it's further away from other stuff and short.
Spencerleehorton
Well-known member
So if we look at the first voltage drop 62v it looks like it drops from 465 to 403v.
This isn’t across any resistor as it’s before the 8.2k.
For me this is where it all gets a bit weird
As looking at the 8.2k it’s 403 - 317 =86
If 8mA is about right then 8200 x 0.008 =65.6v so that’s a good 21v out?
This isn’t across any resistor as it’s before the 8.2k.
For me this is where it all gets a bit weird
As looking at the 8.2k it’s 403 - 317 =86
If 8mA is about right then 8200 x 0.008 =65.6v so that’s a good 21v out?
Spencerleehorton
Well-known member
All my gnds to chassis are separate and not a transformer bolt.
Also I have the 8.2k then 10k then another 10k on the B+ I have an extra 2x 22uf in at the moment but waiting on some 33uf to be delivered.
Also I have the 8.2k then 10k then another 10k on the B+ I have an extra 2x 22uf in at the moment but waiting on some 33uf to be delivered.
yeah can you start a new post with all the up to date info and schematics and layouts. Hard to follow spread out across the different pages. If you can write your voltages on the schematic that would help see where something is getting wrong.
Transformer part numbers, tube models, and what exactly you are doing, and then we can solve the core problems like hum and heat, then move onto extra mods like FX loop, switches, triode/tetrode, etc. It's getting hard to keep track of all the changes you've been making w/o schemo and list of problems and goals.
Transformer part numbers, tube models, and what exactly you are doing, and then we can solve the core problems like hum and heat, then move onto extra mods like FX loop, switches, triode/tetrode, etc. It's getting hard to keep track of all the changes you've been making w/o schemo and list of problems and goals.
Last edited:
So you have several grounds? That may explain everything...
Spencerleehorton
Well-known member
So just to be clear all gnds to star gnd apart from IEC gnd?
Here you can see my three grounds.
So if I move all my gnds from gnd 2 to main gnd this should correct my issues?
Here you can see my three grounds.
So if I move all my gnds from gnd 2 to main gnd this should correct my issues?
Last edited:
It may or may not.
Anyway, having a ground loop so close to the power xfmr is not a good idea.
Spencerleehorton
Well-known member
Yeah bit of a silly mistake there from me as i did read somewhere to keep them seperate to reduce noise but its all changed now to star gnd and still mains txf gets warm.
what i have noticed, with the laser temp tester, the B+ lug on the rectifier pin 8, after 10 minutes its at 50C!!! so im tempted now to let it cool down and take out the GZ34 and put a some diodes in there and test without it.
what i have noticed, with the laser temp tester, the B+ lug on the rectifier pin 8, after 10 minutes its at 50C!!! so im tempted now to let it cool down and take out the GZ34 and put a some diodes in there and test without it.
Spencerleehorton
Well-known member
ive now put the diodes in and put it as per this schematic for solid state and only get 330v on B+, B+ is not connected yet but im assuming that voltage will change once connected to switch and caps and the rest of the B+.
Accelerator
Well-known member
@abbey road d enfer
Dear Mod.With all of my due respect to you I would like very kindly ask you to close this whole uncorrected & dangerous thread as even the title of it “JTM45 Build with 6P3P output tubes and GZ34” it is total uncorrected & dangerous and it will clearly misleading any other new member of our DIY-ers Community for using the total uncorrected 6P3P output tubes in this circuit, not to mention the total uncorrected & dangerous biasing for each of the EL34 Output tubes from 35 − 37𝑚𝐴 to the total uncorrected & dangerous 45mA which it is a value for the KT88 Power tubes, so the member Spencerleehorton will have to open a new one thread, with the current Output tubes that he used now, the current circuit that he is working within it now, the mods that he has done or to maybe he likes to been done to his amplifier, because till this time in this whole Outrange 10-page thread nobody can clearly tell to any new member that will comes to our DIY-ers Community, if we are talking about a Fender Bassman 5F6 amp., a Marshall JTM45 amp., a Marshall JTM50 amp., a Marshall JTM45/100 amp., a Marshall JMP50 amp…
Last edited:
Similar threads
Latest posts
-
-
-
Balancing card (2x unbal-to-bal & 2x bal-to-unbal) R vs G graph added- Latest: MidnightArrakis
-
-
