Transformerless Vari-Mu Compressor

[JohnRoberts]

I don't believe that. Read Designing Value Preamps by Blencowe (aka "merlin" here) about the varied ways tubes clip. Designing a semiconductor-only based circuit to make a little bit of 2nd and 3rd harmonic distortion over a wide range of signal amplitudes and with more or less at different frequencies (LF distortion can easily sound bad) is not at all trivial. I burned a lot of hours trying to make a semiconductor-only based circuit distort like a tube and failed. Even the digital recreations don't sound right IMO. Tubes are inherently more linear than transistors and have much more graceful clipping / starvation characteristics. These characteristics are probably what makes them good for dynamics devices but I say "probably" because I have never made a tube compressor.

There has been a lot of work invested in solid state mimics of tube overload, involving multiple patents.

The approach developed by Peavey marketed as "transtube" was imo pretty successful (but the transtube technology was used in guitar amps, not efx units).

JR

 

[Heikki]

I'm not sure if graceful clipping is why some people like old tube compressors. Lets take a look at RCA BA-6A for example https://groupdiy.com/index.php?topic=44740.msg580840#msg580840. Grid current in the gain reduction stage would cause C1 to charge and clipping would be similar to RC coupled stage. I'm pretty sure the next amplifier stage will clip before the gain reduction stage. I'm not sure if transformer coupled amplifier stage with decent amount of negative feedback will clip any more pleasantly than solid state amplifier.  Assuming of course that the solid state amplifier behaves well when clipping. Since the threshold of limiting is fixed in BA-6A and the attack is fairly fast, I wouldn't expect audible clipping to happen often or ever.

There are of course designs like Sta Level https://groupdiy.com/index.php?topic=44868.msg561651#msg561651 which I would expect to clip much more an more audibly. But I think Sta Level won't clip very gracefully either.

 

[Heikki]

Now I’m trying out a power supply that is powered by a 28VDC wall wart. I’m using DC-DC converters to make 200V for the tubes and +15 and -15V for the INA chips. The power supply is more expensive compared to big lump of iron but makes for very safe DIY.

 

[MaxDM]

I was wondering if you could improve the 'transformerless' designof a vari-mu by keeping the grids grounded and modulating the cathode voltage instead?

You could do this by placing a capacitor between the cathodes of the tube and ground and connecting some kind of low impedance buffer on the cathodes.

So instead of reducing bias voltage on the grids, you would increase the cathode voltage.

the supply voltage for the anodes might need to be a bit higher.

worth a try?

 

[dogears]

Now I’m trying out a power supply that is powered by a 28VDC wall wart. I’m using DC-DC converters to make 200V for the tubes and +15 and -15V for the INA chips. The power supply is more expensive compared to big lump of iron but makes for very safe DIY.

Mind sharing that PSU schematic? Sounds interesting.

 

[abbey road d enfer]

I was wondering if you could improve the 'transformerless' designof a vari-mu by keeping the grids grounded and modulating the cathode voltage instead?

You could do this by placing a capacitor between the cathodes of the tube and ground and connecting some kind of low impedance buffer on the cathodes.

So instead of reducing bias voltage on the grids, you would increase the cathode voltage.

the supply voltage for the anodes might need to be a bit higher.

worth a try?

Haven't you  looked at the original schemo, in post #1?
That is exactly what happens there.
That's why there is a power transistor at the end of teh side-chain.

Check also posts #23 to 28. Jury is still open.

 

[MaxDM]

Haven't you  looked at the original schemo, in post #1?
That is exactly what happens there.
That's why there is a power transistor at the end of teh side-chain.

Check also posts #23 to 28. Jury is still open.

oh wow...

hah, I reinvented the wheel!

Will check the rest of the posts.

 

[Heikki]

Mind sharing that PSU schematic? Sounds interesting.

There's not much to the schematic. It's just DC/DC converters preceded by a linear regulator to make sure the maximum input voltage to the DC/DC converters is not exceeded. Also heater/sidechain supply has it's own linear regulator to make 25V for the heaters

DC/DC converters
https://recom-power.com/pdf/Innoline/Rxx-B.pdf
https://www.tracopower.com/sites/default/files/products/datasheets/tdl3_datasheet.pdf

Wall wart
https://www.meanwell-web.com/en-gb/ac-dc-industrial-wall-mount-adaptor-output-28vdc-gst25e28--p1j

 

[dogears]

Thanks, I'd never come across those RECOM units before. They look nice, but a bit pricey!

 

[Heikki]

Here is the output noise floor with gain at max and nothing connected to the input. (0dBFS = +20dBu)

 

[abbey road d enfer]

Here is the output noise floor with gain at max and nothing connected to the input. (0dBFS = +20dBu)

That's a quite impressive performance. I notice the absence of mains frequency residues.

 

[Heikki]

I notice the absence of mains frequency residues.

That's the advantage using DC/DC converter power supply.

For comparison here's the noise when I used SMPS for heaters and linear power supply for the rest.

 

[abbey road d enfer]

For comparison here's the noise when I used SMPS for heaters and linear power supply for the rest.

There seems to be a significant difference in HF noise too...
The different scales do not allow precise comparison, though.

 

[Heikki]

The different scales do not allow precise comparison, though.

The latter one also has couple dB more gain because I used U-pad for volume control that always attenuates 4dB for the DC/DC supply compressor. For precise comparison I would need to do the measurements again. With these at least the difference in mains frequency residues can be seen.

 

[Heikki]

Here is a better noise comparison. Now the gain is set at 19dB on both compressors. On top is the compressor with AC/DC power supply and at bottom the DC/DC power supply. This time there's a tiny spike at 50Hz even with the DC/DC supply.

 

[abbey road d enfer]

Here is a better noise comparison. Now the gain is set at 19dB on both compressors. On top is the compressor with AC/DC power supply and at bottom the DC/DC power supply. This time there's a tiny spike at 50Hz even with the DC/DC supply.

That's interesting. Actually, the mains residues are much lower but the LF noise is higher, which results in a slightly higher wide-band figure (+0.2dB).

 

[Heikki]

And here is channel 2 from both compressors.

 

[Heikki]

REW has not been cooperating with me lately so I can't do distortion sweeps. Here are couple measurements I did with ARTA.

The soundcard I'm using for measurements isn't the greatest for distortion measurements because the soundcard output has some high frequency noise. Most notably the spike at little over 20kHz.

0dBFS = +20dBu

 

[Heikki]

Here are some distortion measurements with 7dB of gain reduction. In the top picture release was set at slowest. In the middle picture release was at the fastest position. In the bottom one release was at slowest position.

Steady wave distortion measurements with gain reduction aren't really useful. If I want to make them look good I just have to use slow release and higher the frequency the better.

0dBFS = +20dBu

 

[scott2000]

Just listening to the YT video and there are clicks when it goes from -3b to -3db high ratio and from -3db to -5db high ratio....Is this an editing thing??

Also it seems like things get darker (or is it maybe just softer bc more compression..?) when going from -3b high ratio to -5db high ratio.... Granted I've only listened for a minute on headphones but these things kinda jumped out right away... ??