Still not sure what to think. First of all, nice of them they send this info&CD out, free and it arrived very quick.
I think the approach of all clean, no EQ & processing is of course good, but maybe a comparison with both all 'processed' would have been interesting as well. That's harder of course, the result could go in all directions, but it'd perhaps give an idea on how much the different source material could differ in the end result.
I think the Earthworks-set gave a better impression of the room but as (I believe) Soundguy said, you'd better have a good room, otherwise it'll show up.
The kick was indeed underwhelming. but I must say that I'm not too fond of of the D112 sounds either. (but who am I to say that with my limited experience) Too bad the D112 pushed the D12 away, and the '12 looks way cooler as well :wink:
Bye,
Peter