Added a third resistor
I thought there was only one resistor (a 4.7K) initially. Is there a schematic of your power supply?
So I'm assuming that if I wanted to drop it another 80volts, I'd drop in a 32k/2watt resistor? Not sure if that is ok to do.
Well, I don't think your second stage is currently working correctly, a bias of .2V is low. The voltage drop across the power supply resistors will increase when that 2nd stage is pulling more current. Granted, not by a drastic amount, but it should increase.
I also don't know the current of your output stage as you left off the cathode voltage. But dropping 10 volts over a 4k power supply resistor implies that your whole amp is only pulling 2.5mA and the output stage alone should be pulling about twice that amount.
Edit: That seems like too much of a voltage drop needed. Would it be better to get a different transformer all together? Maybe use a tube rectifier to drop the voltage?
Well, it was a little on the high side to begin with. You could put a shunt resistor on the end of the supply to pull more current and drop more voltage across the 4k resistors etc. It's generally a good idea anyway to bleed off caps quicker. Use ohm's law. And don't neglect power dissipation of the resistor, a 1/2w won't do.