Is that the group buy trafo (3402 I think)? IIRC those were 1:8 or so, which should be closer to 18dB gain. 23 is a bit high, but it depends on your measurement methods I guess.
My first thought would be do triple check the wiring to/from the toggles.
Your DC voltages should be fine (as long as they're not reversed
), 2520s should work fine with 15V, but if you can't test them in a known working preamp you are sort of shooting in the dark. You can often tell a faulty opamp from a higher than normal current draw, so if you can test that, it might give you a clue. They should measure pretty low, between 10-20mA normally, going up to 50mA or so going into 600R.
I have make an adapter PCB for an IC opamp on vero board. You can use solid core wire or leads from a TO220 device for the pins, they should fit fine in the opamp sockets. Or, just rig up a DIP8 socket to some solid core wire and plug it directly into the DOA sockets, doesn't have to be pretty, but it will allow you to use an IC opamp rule out the DOAs.
Another thing you could do is wire a DI jack to the DI input (use a 100k or 1M load R between tip and ring), put a small cap in series (maybe in place of the 1K series R), and take the output from after the output cap. If you get nothing, the opamp is not working.
What are those two wimas near the input trafo? Are they part of a zobel network or something else? They're wired to the CZ pads?
output resistor (R21) = ?
I hope I gave you some things to check, let me know how it goes. Otherwise, the build is way cool, I'd love to have a little 2 channel box like that!
Good luck, and post back with news/questions.