Brexit

GroupDIY Audio Forum

Help Support GroupDIY Audio Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
An up to date review of the polls : http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/jun/18/eu-referendum-britain-voting-campaign-jo-cox

Separately I see that someone has started a petition to cancel the referendum altogether on the basis that apparently at least 68% of the MPs in the House of Commons support remaining.  It's fair to say that few other issues have such strong cross-party support, and certainly with that kind of majority wouldn't be put to a public referendum.

For those that aren't from the UK, this online petition is a system whereby anyone can register a petition on the website of the UK government, and if the petition reaches 100,000 (online) signatures, government is obliged to consider the issue for debate in the House of Commons.

As much as I like the idea of these online petitions in general, this one does strike me as a tactic employed by someone who suddenly doesn't expect the easy victory they did a few weeks ago, and is trying whatever they can to avoid an unfavourable outcome (for themselves / the Remain camp)
 
A few years ago there was a big scandal in the UK when a leading newspaper published the expense claims of MPs. Many of these were very large and many of a dubious nature. The public was naturally incensed. When nobody was sacked, a few were asked to pay back some money back and just a couple prosecuted, the public's opinion of its politicians dropped to an all time low. The result was a general election that led to a the first coalition government in the UK since WWII. The bottom line is the UK public has an all time low opinion of its politicians  and the style of the referendum campaign has done nothing but reinforce this view. When all the major party leaders trot out a diatribe of doom and gloom if we leave the EU you can be sure many people think they are only saying it to maintain the status quo and hold on to their cushy jobs.

Cheers

Ian
 
Yes, I totally see that first point about people being fed up with politicians. But who elected them in the first place (wasn't it the people)? And who passed on the chance in the last elections to "take control" where it really matters, namely at the local level? This is a phenomenon not exclusive to the UK, and to stay fair, the second half (keep their cushy jobs) surely also holds true for the 'leave' camp (some even seem keen on taking over those cushy jobs).

What has happened/is happening in several EU countries lately is that this kind of dissatisfaction and  disgust with politicians all too easily falls for the first bunch of faces that come across polite in demeanour but rumbunctious in content, and stick their fingers to the entire establishment. Yeah, finally somebody is telling them suckers off, let's go support them to show those 'cushy job holders' what it feels like to not being listened to...

Problem is that this is not what this referendum is about.
 
This guy is now leading the leave campaign.

Here's what he said a short while back

http://news.sky.com/story/1714036/video-reveals-boris-supported-eu-single-market.

Now we are being asked to follow his advice to leave, this is why I don't trust him or his motives.

Every respected institution around the World has warned us not to leave, are they all in some worldwide conspiracy?

I don't think so, I think they may simply be telling the truth.  It is one hell of a gamble when the world has changed so much since the last time we were OUT in the 60's.

DaveP
 
I am hoping that the British who live in the EU will make a positive difference when their votes are taken into the final result.

Postal votes have already been returned in most cases and this is the rough breakdown of the numbers:-

Spain:            400k
France:        200k
Germany:    100k
Italy:                80k

There are also many hundreds of thousands living in the US, Canada, Australia who may have voted as well.  I don't think that these little polls of 1 or 2 thousand people include Brits living abroad, but who are still able to vote.

DaveP
 
I don't want to walk away from people like these

https://youtu.be/GBaHPND2QJg

DaveP
 
DaveP said:
I am hoping that the British who live in the EU will make a positive difference when their votes are taken into the final result.

Postal votes have already been returned in most cases and this is the rough breakdown of the numbers:-

Spain:            400k
France:        200k
Germany:    100k
Italy:                80k

There are also many hundreds of thousands living in the US, Canada, Australia who may have voted as well.  I don't think that these little polls of 1 or 2 thousand people include Brits living abroad, but who are still able to vote.

DaveP
Did those numbers vote for or against leaving?

I thought the campaigns quieted down somewhat to show respect for the MP who was killed.

JR
 
JR,

The campaigns have restarted after 3 days.

Those are the numbers living abroad, it seems unlikely they will vote to leave, or else why live there?

DaveP
 
Script said:
Yes, I totally see that first point about people being fed up with politicians. But who elected them in the first place (wasn't it the people)? And who passed on the chance in the last elections to "take control" where it really matters, namely at the local level? This is a phenomenon not exclusive to the UK, and to stay fair, the second half (keep their cushy jobs) surely also holds true for the 'leave' camp (some even seem keen on taking over those cushy jobs).

What has happened/is happening in several EU countries lately is that this kind of dissatisfaction and  disgust with politicians all too easily falls for the first bunch of faces that come across polite in demeanour but rumbunctious in content, and stick their fingers to the entire establishment. Yeah, finally somebody is telling them suckers off, let's go support them to show those 'cushy job holders' what it feels like to not being listened to...

Problem is that this is not what this referendum is about.

That is exactly what this referendum is about. Is is a vote of confidence/no confidence in the UK and EU governments.

Cheers

Ian
 
rob_gould said:
For those that aren't from the UK, this online petition is a system whereby anyone can register a petition on the website of the UK government, and if the petition reaches 100,000 (online) signatures, government is obliged to consider the issue for debate in the House of Commons.

As much as I like the idea of these online petitions in general, this one does strike me as a tactic employed by someone who suddenly doesn't expect the easy victory they did a few weeks ago, and is trying whatever they can to avoid an unfavourable outcome (for themselves / the Remain camp)
We have a similar petition process here where 100k signatures gets a response from the white house.

I am not big fan of simple democracy (tyranny of the masses), web petitions remind me of the futuristic science fiction where the public decides which gladiators on TV live or die.  Real time voting is probably harmless for deciding singing contests, but less so for more weighty matters.

JR
 
Reminds me a bit of discussing with my brother :)

No matter what the outcome of this in-or-out, yes-or-no, black-or-white, sickness-or-nausea referendum, I really hope for all Brits that it brings them what they think is 'best' or rather---since this is Britain after all---what is 'less bad'. I spent some of my life time in this jolly country, and depending on who will be swinging the political sceptre there in the future, I'm back to the drawing board.

BTW, did you hear about that pub selling 'In' and 'Out' beer?
 
Script said:
Reminds me a bit of discussing with my brother :)

No matter what the outcome of this in-or-out, yes-or-no, black-or-white, sickness-or-nausea referendum, I really hope for all Brits that it brings them what they think is 'best' or rather---since this is Britain after all---what is 'less bad'. I spent some of my life time in this jolly country, and depending on who will be swinging the political sceptre there in the future, I'm back to the drawing board.

BTW, did you hear about that pub selling 'In' and 'Out' beer?
In california you can get in and out burgers. 
150px-InNOut.svg.png


JR
 
DaveP said:
This guy is now leading the leave campaign.

Here's what he said a short while back

http://news.sky.com/story/1714036/video-reveals-boris-supported-eu-single-market.

Now we are being asked to follow his advice to leave, this is why I don't trust him or his motives.

Why is it a problem that he changed his views?  Would you take Baroness Warsi's advice who has just switched side because "apparently"  the leave campaign has taken a racist attitude towards  immigration? I am a  first generation immigrant in this country and even I have had it enough with this un-controlled immigration.


Every respected institution around the World has warned us not to leave, are they all in some worldwide conspiracy?

I don't think so, I think they may simply be telling the truth.  It is one hell of a gamble when the world has changed so much since the last time we were OUT in the 60's.

DaveP

Yeap.

They were telling us how great the world economy was doing until we hit the rock bottom overnight.  Listen to what Michael Gove is saying. We will be facing exactly the same economic challenges if we remain.

....... the idea that Britain could not trade successfully outside the EU is "absolute cobblers".

James Dyson

I am not drumming up "leave" but trying to be objective.
 
I read recently an article by a guy who went on a camping holoday to France. Whilst there he met some French friends who introduced them to some of their Dutch friends. He spoke to the Dutch friends and to many other Dutch people at the camp site. They all said they thought the UK was lucky to be getting a chance to vote to leave the EU.  They joined the EU in 1958 and said it is now nothing like it was originally intended to be. They said if they had a referendum  now they would definitely vote to leave.

I wonder how people in other EU countries feel?

Cheers

Ian
 
And ask Norway, surprisingly! Like Britain, they have their own currency, pay a lot into the EU, but get zero rebate (as far as I know). Another big difference is that Norway is 'smaller' than Britain, seems richer (household average), and importantly, has much lower unemployment, as far as I know.

I'm not sure how knowing what other people in the EU think could help Britains in their decision at all. For every person saying they too would leave, there is another person saying they'd stay. The answer to this simply depends on who you ask and what newspapers you read. The reasons are all on the table, some explained better in detail than others. Although, I sadly have to admit, both campaign sides did an appallingly poor job in explaining. Rather it all sounded like the same slogans and commercial-like propaganda phrases (only one example: that ex-German Gisela-oh- my-finger-raised -itself-I-think- my-mind-has-occured-another-metaphor-for-you -- whatever her name is) being buckled over and over again. Especially 'debates' on British TV (I'm referring to both sides indiscriminately!) have caused me more than one fit of severe colon pain.

Let me say this, I guess everybody across the EU envies the Brits for three things:
- being a beautiful, proud country
- having a say in a referendum
- having that very special position within the EU

Here's what I think.

Within the next few decades, Europe will suffer a blow to its significance on the world economy map anyway, as China is lurking on the horizon. Yes, I know, the Chinese economy isn't doing as great as it used to (no 10%, no 7% of growth any more, only 6 point whatever), but hey, it's still doing way better than anybody thinks, and if they don't blow it entirely, they still have huge potential. Just right now they are on a big company-buying spree across Europe! Personally, I don't see this as a big problem (I like the Chinese, and their food), but still, after juggernaut China comes jugn'raut India and whoever else, and they will all catch up rather sooner than later. That's also one of the reasons why I'd rather see European countries stay close together.

Several EU countries, including Britain, have seen a series of governments systematically pushing wages down (in Britain ever since Thatcherism). And now they follow the fetish of 'austerity'. I'm not convinced that's an entirely good idea. Yes, it puts a stop to increasing state debts, but it also makes many people suffer, and it's always the wrong people suffering. It is just a matter of time that they got really angry (we are already seeing it: right-leaning parties and groups gaining ground across the EU). Here’s the funny thing: I know everybody hates Mr. Draghi and his printing press. However, Dracula et al. keep repeating that this economic experiment (i.e., reducing state debts by reducing purchasing power, accompanied by restructuring of debts toward cheaper conditions) can only be successful if local governments across the entire EU also implement structural (read: social!) reforms. They keep repeating it. But I don't see many countries doing that. Instead they all too often keep following the neo2-liberal course as if it we were still living the golden old days of the economic wonder years. The other day I read a specialist paper (can't remember by who though) claiming that any country can easily afford new and higher debts as long as inflation (read: interest rate) stays below 5% (which it will, cos -- let's face it -- the EU, and the US I think, have been in hidden recession for several years already, with the printing presses covering it up) and, the paper continues, that new debts will pay off in one or two decades. Maybe they would, maybe they won't. But it's a daring thought! Anyway, I do see the ECB and the EU trying to give us all a rather ‘soft landing’, but I can easily identify local (read: national) governments not getting into gear. And that is our all fault as voters!

At the same time, there is huge progress with regard to corporate and private tax avoidance across the EU and beyond; the entire banking sector is massively changing and being changed; financial market regulations are being put (back!?) into place (state debt crisis? pah, what we see is still the aftermath of the 08/09 financial crisis) etc etc etc etc. It's weird that any progress in these fields hardly ever features big (or at all) in the news. I guess they think nobody is interested, and I think they are wrong. They should try harder in explaining. And yeah, I know, it's all ever soooo slow, but some of these changes wouldn't be possible at all without the EU.

Immigration? To EU or not to EU, these people don't ask, they are coming anyway. Political refugees, we have to take them – like it or not. And those others? Didn’t Austria just do something that amounts to closing their borders? It's just another country going that direction (basically illegal). Do we hear any other EU country complaining about it? No, not really! And then there is also that dodgy deal with Turkey (a country I don’t see in the EU for decades to come). Anyway, there were experts warning to get prepared for masses of people coming. Now they have arrived and they keep coming. Either way I'd say cure the disease not the symptoms. The easy fix: withdrawal -- but that's not a cure! Sure, the EU will also have to alleviate symptoms and they should do so rather quickly.

In coming back to what other EU countries are thinking, I read several articles in which influential politicians across the EU are more or less saying: No matter whether the UK leaves or remains, the EU will have to change. So they seem to have heard the bang already. Let's hope it'll be more than just lip service. I really like the idea of them all sitting at a table working it out together -- that's what I call democracy. Sure, they all will have to compromise (agree to lose something to get something else in return) and we all know...

The worst thing about a compromise is it's a compromise.
 
sahib said:
They were telling us how great the world economy was doing until we hit the rock bottom overnight.  Listen to what Michael Gove is saying. We will be facing exactly the same economic challenges if we remain.

Absolutely the last individual in Parliament I'd trust on any issue.  Even discounting his recent Exit-related remarks like comparing pro-Remain economists to Nazis or simply making up numbers to support his arguments, the damage that he did to the British education system during his time as Education Secretary ought to be illustration enough about his feelings of duty to the electorate.  An exceptionally dangerous individual.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top