mulletchuck said:
So, i'm sure this question should be reserved for a thread all by itself, but if the sound that really defined the u47 mic was the tube that was used, why isn't anyone cloning that tube? Wasn't there a vid about some guy who made tubes by hand over in france?
I don't know that the U47 sound is so much the tube as it is the capsule + headbasket + tube operating points + transformer combo. I theorize that one could approach a similar sound with many types of tubes if the operating points are set correctly and then combined with the other elements mentioned previously. I think this is what Max was shooting for with the MK7, then the MK47.
So why no VF14 clones? Let me make some guesses:
• the technical documents needed to understand part materials, specs, geometries, manufacturing process, and construction are probably scarce or non-existent
• the machinery needed to build tubes would require hundreds of thousands of dollars to purchase
• also, all such machinery is decades old at this point and not necessarily in peak operating condition
• the handful of tube manufacturing houses still in business today (JJ, EHX, Chinese, ?) would need to invest tens if not hundred of thousands on R&D and tooling to develop a new tube for manufacture, such as the VF14
• the VF14 cannot be made by hand in the same manner that the French dude in the video makes glass triodes. (fingers crossed someone will prove me wrong!)
So, there's really no return on investment—much less profit. You'd probably need to sell 5000 units @ $200 to break even.
I don't feel that there's anything special about the VF14 sound-wise. I could always change my mind at a later date, but that's how I feel now.
If one WERE to clone the VF14, here's what you'd need to build inside a steel vacuum:
zayance said:
http://www.telefunken-elektroakustik.com/products/vacuum-tubes.php
But not for individual purchase...
This tube is bunk. It's a glass WE 408a inside of a metal or plastic housing made to look like a VF14. Nothing special.
http://www.gearslutz.com/board/moan-zone/369572-vf14k-tube.html
http://recforums.prosoundweb.com/index.php/mv/msg/26925/0/0/0/
If you want the sound of the "VF14k", search eBay for "408a tube," buy one for $2.00 (give or take), and install it with a resistor as shown the the above threads.