Hi Consul,
I can relate to you a great deal here. I still feel like the mixes I used to do on my Fostex or Yamaha 4-Track rival anything I've done on 1/2" 8 Track, ADAT, or my current MOTU/Digital Performer/Aardsync II/ G4 rig.
I was 19 in my bedroom listening to some tape out of a book on recording technique thinking, "This sounds like crap compared to the stuff I'm doing on my little 4-Track!"
Every thing just came out somewhat tasty with a tendency to gel. Friends were always impressed. Sure, it was noisy and didn't have the highs and lows of a commercial product, but in a way I feel like I've been on a downward slide ever since then. Perhaps my perspective has just changed a lot. I was much more of a musician back then than I am now. The technical stuff has almost completely snuffed out the creative guitar player I once was. I've got a nice studio now, though. I'm about ready to buy another cheap, used 4-Track to see if I can re-kindle the flame.
Dean